This week I saw Black Mass, the new film from director Scott Cooper (Out of the Furnace). The film stars Oscar nominee Johnny Depp, Joel Edgerton (The Gift), Benedict Cumberbath (Star Trek Into Darkness), Kevin Bacon, Corey Stoll (This is Where I Leave You), Peter Sarsgaard (Blue Jasmine) and Dakota Johnson (50 Shades of Grey). The film has been promoted as the "official" beginning of the Oscar season. Its mid-September release date puts it in a weird position, however. The Oscar season is long and fickle, meaning the film could be forgotten by time December hits. Black Mass' best contender is star Depp himself as notorious criminal James "Whitey" Bulger, whose performance in the film is being touted as a "comeback" but he still needs strong legs at the box office to retain the momentum.
But why is the movie considered an Oscar
contender? Johnny Depp is laughably phony in the lead role, desperately vying for street cred by cursing on screen and staring at people. But this is no less a caricature than his work in Dark Shadows or the later Pirates of the Caribbean movies. Black Mass is a standard gangster biopic, where bad guys do bad things
but look cool doing it and then get caught and we're supposed to
understand that they're bad. It features overwritten dialogue that tries
hard to be macho-poetic, throwing in the F word and other profanity to
sound hardcore. This movie is reeking of testosterone and toxic
masculinity. The movie is deemed "important" because it has the veneer
of a prestige mobster move but in fact it is just as hollow as any
studio programmed rom-com or blockbuster.