Okay now we can begin. As How I Met Your Mother enters its 8th season, I think it's appropriate to look back at the show's most memorable, surprising and, yes, legendary episodes.
The first nine episodes of How I Met Your Mother are great and special. But it wasn't until The Pineapple Incident that the show really found its groove. It was the first time the show used its now signature time-jumping narrative style to tell the story, rather than just for flashbacks. This episode also features Drunk Ted (my favorite of Ted's personas, with Pretentious Ted as a close second) and it introduces fan favorite Trudy who would later return in another classic episode Third Wheel. This episode is pretty amazing because it unfolds like a mystery, but the most curious aspect of the mystery--the origin of the pineapple--remains unsolved.
Ted and Victoria are such a great couple that it comes as a shock when you look back and realize they only had about 4 episodes in season 1 as a couple. The last of which, Cupcake, presents a very compelling relationship problem: the threat of long distance, even more distressing since their relationship is so new and vulnerable. The evolution of their thoughts about this issue is brilliantly done, especially since its coated with Robin's hilarious jealousy, Marshall and Lily talking about their own long distance troubles and Barney's own long distance relationships (yes, that's plural because it's Barney). Marshall buying a suit in the back of a pet shop? Lily sitting in a cake and destorying a wedding dress? Typical HIMYM realistic absurdity.
One of HIMYM's strengths is its refusal to put the characters on a pedestal. These 5 characters are seriously flawed people (with Marshall being the closest to being the perfect guy). Nothing Good is such a sad episode, with Ted making bad nighttime decisions and screwing up his friendship with Robin. Robin herself is extremely vulnerable and doesn't even know what she's doing. Whenever their A-plot is going on, the episode is extremely well-written and performed. The B-plot with Korean Elvis hangin' with Marshall, Lily and Barney is a little weak but, well, nothing good happens after 2 A.M.
Other season 1 highlights: Mary the Paralegal, Drumroll Please, The Duel, Best Prom Ever and of course the Pilot.
I don't know how popular or acclaimed this episode is but I just love it. HIMYM played a very risky game by putting commitment-phobe Robin in a relationship with commitment-hungry Ted. It became even riskier since, gosh, they are an excellent couple. We saw so much of Ted pursuing Robin that it's almost refreshing to see Robin go a little crazy with jealousy when she thought Ted was with another girl. And the reveal that it was Barney the whole time? Genius. Also Marshall's law school friends talking about relationships in legalese--hysterical. At the end of the day, it is nice to see Robin appreciating that Ted is a great and loyal boyfriend by bringing him donuts (filled with jelly but she's not bragging).
Slap Bet will probably go down in history as HIMYM's best episode (or one of the best). And that is pretty accurate. Like all terrific episodes, it is very silly and absurd but grounded in very realistic themes. Here, secrets in a relationship--good or bad? Robin is keeping a secret about why she hates malls and Marshall and Barney have a slap bet about it. Both plots are full of very funny material (Lily as power hungry Slap Bet Commissioner is a highlight) And this episode contains probably my favorite line in the entire series. Ted: You're crazy--no wonder your fake husband moved to Hong Kong! Robin: He moved there for business!! Of course, the show throws a curveball and made Robin a teenage Canadian pop star named Robin Sparkles whose one hit "Let's Go to the Mall" led to a year of performing in a mall. It's all so funny and surprising--did anyone see that coming?
Marshall and Lily's journey into adulthood has always been one of HIMYM's strongest subplots, one that started in Season 1, Episode 5's Okay Awesome and continues through today. This landmark episode showcases the origin of Marshall's beloved Fiero and how it changed each of the gang's lives. Barney sort of learned to drive (and hates the car), Marshall and Ted became best friends in the car as did Lily and Robin. The episode is also an excellent example of how the show doesn't really need a plot--a framing device and some great flashbacks can make a great episode. Marshall says Arrivederci to his Fiero, one of the first steps into the realization that growing up is both difficult and necessary. "But i would walk 500 miles and I would walk 500 miles..."
Other season 2 highlights: Brunch, Lucky Penny, Stuff, First Time in New York, Something Blue
Trudy's triumphant return is in the episode where Ted has a threesome. Or doesn't. Or does. Or doesn't. (I think he did.) This episode is so funny with Marshall, Lily and Barney coaching Ted on how to get a threesome without ruining it and the jokes come fast. Trudy and Rachel (played by Cougar Town's Busy Phillips before Cougar Town aired) are funny and charming so the whole setup doesn't seem too icky. Unfortunately Robin gets stuck with a lame B-plot but considering she and Ted just broke up, it seems natural that they wouldn't include her in the threesome shenanigans.
Season 3 gets a lot of flack for being rushed but it aired the year of the 2007 Writers Strike which meant it was a shortened season. This was the last episode to air before the show went on its 3 month, 1 week hiatus. And it's a perfect, classical episode of HIMYM. It puts a new spin on relationships (8 stages of relationships when you see the person every day), has immaculate editing (Barney's story, Marshall and Lily's story and Robin's story all playing out simultaneously even though happening in different years), and the writing is sharp and hysterical. This episode is a great sampling of what makes How I Met Your Mother so unique and wonderful. Great running gags, quirky supporting characters and a meaty part for Wendy the Waitress--who could ask for anything more?
And here we are, my favorite episode of the entire series. The episode is so funny with Ted, Lily and Robin all giving Marshall un-helpful advice about how to deal with corporate screaming. Lily's sexually frustrated since Marshall is working too much (Horny Lily is one of her best personas, along with Ghetto Lily and Drunk Lily), Ted suggests an impassioned speech and Robin uses guns. Of course, this is the one arena where Barney actually knows what he's talking about and he helps Marshall survive Corporate America. Like I said before, I've always been a fan of Marshall and Lily's journey to maturity and this episode is a great example. And the stuff with Ted's new car? It's all vintage HIMYM shenanigans and craziness. This is a good ensemble episode (though Marshall and Barney get some of the best scenes like the one in the diner).
Other season 3 highlights: Miracles, Dowiesetrepla, Sandcastles in the Sand, Ten Sessions and How I Met Everyone Else
So that's it for part 1. For part 2, click here.
2 comments:
Great synopsis
Not a too bad list, but I really miss Swarley, Atlantic City and How Lily Stole Christmas with the Season 2 episodes.
- Swarley comes with a great A-plot, assuming that the title refers to the A-plot of Barney being stuck with a nickname. The B-plot is just as strong, with Lily realizing once more the size of the mistake she made, and she even went out of her way to make sure Marshall doesn't date a pretty girl. Their reunion as a couple is the mini-cherry on top of the regular cherry on top of the sundae of awesomeness that is this episode.
- Atlantic City is mainly one of my favorite because of the B-plot, Ted being all turned on by Robin's bathing suit, and eventually sleeping together due to it. Marshall and Lily'eagerness to suddenly get married is a little over the top, but they realize that themselves, so that makes up.
- Of course, How Lily Stole Christmas is one of the best episodes that really showcase Ted and Lily's relationship in the early show. And the feels, although it could have been done with a little more emotion other than anger. It shows that, as Lily left, she completely forgot she also left Ted, as well as Robin and Barney, which could have been worked out more. But for the rest, it was a great episode, with a sick Barney as a christmas bonus.
Post a Comment